And it’s out. The much-anticipated Joss Whedon project that
gives us weekly doses of live-action Marvel adventure. And, I have to say, I’m
underwhelmed. Pilots are not necessarily an indication of a good or bad season,
but this one felt clichéd and uninspired. I came to it with high hopes – I’m a
big fan of Whedon’s Firefly/Serenity
and Much Ado About Nothing, and I
can’t ever seem to get enough superhero action. The opening sequences were
exciting. They combined a made-for-television superhero world like Alphas with the espionage panache of Covert Affairs. But as the episode progressed,
the spy genre was dropped in favor of developing the superhero-y world. And
that might have been a good choice, if Whedon had anything interesting or new
to say about the genre. Instead, he siphons off The Avengers’ mythos in an attempt that feels like trying to
channel that film’s success into a TV format. And it doesn’t work. The Avengers’ main appeal, to me at
least, was the eye-candy. It had exciting fight sequences that spanned the front
wall of a movie theater, not to mention gorgeous people in form-fitting
costumes. But even nerd auteur Whedon can’t reproduce that very cinematic
experience on TV. What I think he can do, based on his previous projects, is
develop an interesting narrative arc. And when he finishes off-loading
exposition and allows himself to create an artistic boundary between Agents and Avengers, I think that this could become a compelling new show.
Monday, September 30, 2013
Friday, September 27, 2013
Cymbeline
The Oregon Shakespeare Festival, for as long as I can
remember, has had hits and misses just like any other theater. Sometimes they
even happen in the same show, and sometimes they’re distinct enough that they
can be attributed to specific jobs within the production. Cymbeline is just such a show.
Image from the Eureka Times-Standard |
OSF has always attracted the cream of the crop in terms of
actors. This cast is mostly superb, with stand-out performances by Dawn-Lyen
Gardner as (the play’s real lead) Imogen, Daniel José Molina as the impetuously
fatalistic Posthumus, Kenajuan Bentley as the ever-suave creep Iachimo, and
Donovan Mitchell as the adorable little brother Arviragus aka Cadwal. These
four actors ground Shakespeare’s ridiculously involved soap-opera of a plot
with honest and often playful interactions with the convoluted world in which
they find themselves.
Cymbeline loses
its grounding in its direction. Director Bill Rauch and costume designer David
C. Woolard chose to add “a few mythical creatures to populate a landscape in
which miraculous surprise lies beyond every bend in the story” (from Rauch’s
program note). The goat-men and pig-men and people with pointy ears confused an
already confusing story. That’s not to say it was a bad choice – in fact, I
feel it was a good choice used sloppily. Kate McConnell writes in OSF’s Illuminations: A Guide to the 2013 Plays
about Shakespeare’s “green worlds”:
“This ‘green world’ (a term coined by literary critic
Northrop Frye), separated from the rules and organization of urbanity, gives
the characters space to transform (sometimes literally), fall in and out of
love, and discover who they truly are. In Cymbeline,
the wilds of Wales
perform this function….For the characters who travel to this place,
transformation and revelation await.”
Rauch could have used his mythological creatures to
emphasize Wales
as a place of transformation and lent clarity to the story. Instead, this
choice read as superfluous at best, and at worst, confusing.
Rauch’s casting Howie Seago as the titular king was also
ill-advised. Seago is deaf and communicates via ASL. The way this plays on
stage is that he delivers his lines in ASL and another actor interprets for
those of us not schooled enough to understand sign-language. The effect is that
Cymbeline’s tempestuousity is scattered across the stage, diluting its power
and weakening the impact of the play’s main power-broker. Not that Seago is a
bad actor – in fact, from what I can see, he is very accomplished in his craft.
It’s just that, unfortunately, his lack of hearing is very much a handicap when
it comes to acting Shakespeare.
Cymbeline is a play in which Shakespeare revels in his
accomplishments as a storyteller by creating a labyrinthine plot that ranges from
the improbable to the confusing. With such a play, it’s the artistic team’s job
to clarify and ground the plot. OSF’s actors for the most part are successful
in this. Unfortunately, they receive no help from their director, whose choices
add further layers to an already excessively layered play.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)